top of page
Writer's pictureMarc Stuart

Reconciliation of Mediumship and Faith




Welcome back to our blog, where we delve into the fascinating intersections of spirituality, religion, and the mysteries that lie beyond our physical existence. Today, we have some intriguing news to share: Marc has recently made contact with a very strange spirit, and we've captured this extraordinary experience on video. This encounter has sparked an upgrade in our AI system, and we're looking for people to test it, particularly focusing on how it handles links and resources.


Our goal in this conversation is to explore how mediumship—as direct evidence of life after death—relates to and sometimes contradicts religious beliefs. This topic is not just theoretical; it has real-world implications. For instance, Marc once had to ban a law PhD student from our clinic and head office due to her contentious statements about mediumship, highlighting the challenges that arise when spiritual practices collide with established beliefs.


Defining Spiritual Mediumship as Proof of Life After Death


Before we dive deeper, let's clarify what we mean by mediumship. Spiritual mediumship is the practice of providing direct evidence of life after death through communication with spirits. Mediums act as intermediaries between the physical world and the spirit realm, delivering messages that often offer comfort, closure, and insight.


Now, we acknowledge that this concept can be challenging or even controversial for those with Christian religious beliefs. In Christianity, the resurrection of Jesus is taken as proof of life after death and serves as evidence of God's power. In contrast, while many other major religions include life after death as a component of their beliefs, they don't necessarily consider it proof of a creator.

Interestingly, spiritualism doesn't take proof of life after death as proof of a creator. We've posed this question in many churches, and the responses vary widely, reflecting the diverse interpretations and beliefs within religious communities. (And yes, we realize we've been focusing a lot on women in our last two talks—so consider this our "LAD" talk, but not the kind you might be thinking!)


What Mediumship and Religion Have in Common


Despite the differences, mediumship and religion share several core values. Both believe in the existence of a soul, an afterlife, and the desire for spiritual connection. They aim to offer comfort, hope, and a sense of meaning beyond our physical lives.

One way to illustrate these shared values is through the Seven Principles of Spiritualism, which many religions would agree with:


  1. The Fatherhood of God: Recognizing a creative force in the universe, often referred to as God, which manifests in all things.

  2. The Brotherhood of Man: Acknowledging that all humans are part of one large family, emphasizing mutual support and understanding.

  3. The Communion of Spirits and the Ministry of Angels: Believing in the possibility of communication with departed spirits, facilitated through mediumship, and the guidance provided by spirit entities.

  4. The Continuous Existence of the Human Soul: Affirming that the human soul continues to exist after physical death, maintaining personal identity.

  5. Personal Responsibility: Emphasizing that individuals are responsible for their own actions and the consequences thereof.

  6. Compensation and Retribution Hereafter for all the Good and Evil Deeds done on Earth: Asserting that individuals will experience consequences for their actions, both good and bad, in the afterlife.

  7. Eternal Progress Open to Every Human Soul: Believing that every soul has the opportunity for continuous growth and development in the afterlife.


These principles resonate with many religious teachings, highlighting the common ground between mediumship and established faiths.


Contradictions and Challenges in Combining Mediumship with Religion

However, combining mediumship with religion isn't without its contradictions and challenges. Let's discuss some specific points of contention:


  1. Faith vs. Evidence: Many religions encourage faith without the need for physical proof, whereas mediumship attempts to provide direct evidence of life after death. This raises the question: Is proof of life after death also proof of God, or does it complicate the idea of faith in a higher power?

  2. Authority: Religious texts and leaders are often seen as the ultimate authority on matters of the afterlife. Mediums, offering direct and personal experiences, can sometimes present information that contradicts traditional teachings.

  3. Titles and Recognition: In the United States, many mediums use the title "Reverend," while in the UK, mediums often avoid such titles. This could be due to the Spiritualist Church being more established and recognized as a major religion in the UK, affecting how mediums align themselves with religious institutions.

  4. Views on Communication with the Dead: Some religions discourage or even forbid communication with the dead, viewing it as spiritually dangerous or forbidden. Mediumship, on the other hand, embraces this communication as a path to connection and healing.


From the Bible itself, several passages caution against consulting mediums and spiritists:


  • Leviticus 19:31: "Do not turn to mediums or seek out spiritists, for you will be defiled by them. I am the LORD your God."

  • Leviticus 20:6: "I will set my face against anyone who turns to mediums and spiritists... and will cut them off from their people."

  • Deuteronomy 18:10-12: "Let no one be found among you... who is a medium or spiritist or who consults the dead. Anyone who does these things is detestable to the LORD."

  • Isaiah 8:19: "When someone tells you to consult mediums and spiritists... should not a people inquire of their God? Why consult the dead on behalf of the living?"


Why Is This Interpretation Challenged?


These passages have been interpreted in various ways, and some argue that they should be understood in the context of the times:


  • Contextual Interpretation: The prohibitions in the Bible may have been directed at specific practices prevalent at the time, which are not equivalent to contemporary mediumship. The Hebrew words translated as "medium" or "spiritist" might refer to practices involving sorcery or idolatry, rather than the compassionate communication aimed at healing today.

  • Spiritual Gifts: Certain Christian denominations, particularly within the Charismatic and Pentecostal movements, believe in the continuation of spiritual gifts, including prophecy and discernment of spirits. The New Testament acknowledges these gifts within the church, as seen in 1 Corinthians 12:10, which mentions "the working of miracles, to another prophecy, to another discerning of spirits." This perspective holds that when practiced under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, such gifts are legitimate and beneficial.

  • Mediumship as a Divine Gift: Organizations like the Churches' Fellowship for Psychical and Spiritual Studies suggest that mediumship, when approached with discernment and caution, can offer comfort and guidance to those seeking spiritual experiences.


Balancing Mediumship and Religious Beliefs


Despite the challenges, many individuals have managed to reconcile their belief in life after death through mediumship while maintaining their religious faith. For example, the UK-based Christian Spiritualist Churches blend elements of Christianity with spiritualist practices, embracing mediumship as part of their worship and community.


This leads us to consider: Was Jesus a powerful medium? Some interpret his miracles and messages as signs of profound spiritual connection, suggesting that reading the Bible too literally might overlook its descriptions of mediumship-like experiences.

For those navigating conflicting views, focusing on shared values like love, hope, and the belief in an afterlife can be a practical way forward. Engaging in open dialogue, seeking common ground, and respecting diverse interpretations can help bridge the gap between mediumship and traditional religious beliefs.


Conclusion


The exploration of mediumship in the context of religion opens up profound questions about faith, evidence, and the nature of our existence. While contradictions exist, the shared values and goals provide a foundation for mutual understanding. Whether one seeks proof or embraces faith without evidence, the pursuit of spiritual connection remains a universal human endeavor.

We invite you to share your thoughts and experiences on this topic. How do you perceive the relationship between mediumship and religion? Let's continue this conversation and explore the mysteries together.

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page